Choosing Art for a Gift
Giving pictures or artwork of any kind as a gift
is a good idea but it can become quite a puzzler. Everyone wants their gifts to be appreciated and hope they will be enjoyed.
We’ll look at real-life responses we have experienced with people on the receiving end that may help you make a good choice.
I spent many years helping people to choose frames for pictures that they brought in to our shop in London.
The process of choosing involved talking about what they felt about the picture, where it came from
how they had acquired it and so on, and very often they were presents from someone they knew or somebody in their family or even a person they had not even met.
Guiding customers through the options gave me years of experience with the feelings of the receiver of a present as well as an insight into givers of presents.
Believe me I’ve seen the whole gamut of reactions to the gifts people receive,
all the way from dismissive to embarrassment, to delight.
I’ve heard great long stories explaining how they came to have this present and the feelings they have about it.
I have also had just a curt instruction to have the thing Framed
While I was doing the usual helping thing with those who enjoyed exploring the options we’d have lots of fun and try plenty of solutions and it could take quite a while.
Well that’s alright that’s fine.
I became totally involved with the process and their stories and it was not until later that I realised how much I learnt.
I learnt a lot about character and love.
And pride came into it both in good way and perhaps not so good too. Sometimes people are proud to have been given the gift and sometimes their pride would prevent them from enjoying it fully.
In the role of helping to choose the display you get people showing you things and having to give you one opinion while feeling another, perhaps because the person who gave it to them was there.
Sometimes you get a completely different story when they came back alone to pick up.
With some people there was a lot of emotion attached to the item that they had brought in.
I refer to the artwork as ‘the item’ because they could be objects or pictures.
It was evident that most of these presents had been given a lot of thought by the
people who gave them.
They didn’t get it right every time.
In fact sometimes you wondered what on earth they were thinking. Did they really know the person they were giving to at all?
Well of course, sometimes they didn’t.
They might have just met the person.
Let’s say the gift is for:
- their son’s new girlfriend
- their husband’s new boss
- somebody they wanted to thank for a service
But some givers had the ability to cause even people like that to be delighted
or at least pleased and happy to keep it,
and display it.
Responses To Receiving Art Gifts
Some reactions to presents that go down well.
You remembered just what they wanted, or you bought it when you saw it with her.
Look, it’s the very one I wished I could buy when we went to that exhibition. He must have sneaked back and bought it for me – and he’s kept it hidden all this time!
When you know them well, visit them regularly and pay attention to their taste you can be guided by that.
Yes I know exactly where it will hang – I’ve been going on about the space above the sofa and the colours in the room. I left colour charts lying on the coffee table, laid out with the colours that work as a contrast. She certainly understands what I like.
Work colleagues sometimes have a reason to give. If you are buying as a group it a good idea to ask someone who knows them well, perhaps a wife and husband might have been discussing a room together. If you can contact their partner or a close friend it could be very helpful.
My staff got together and gave me this for my 50th – Isn’t it amazing? It’s by one of my favorite artists, and I’m so lucky it’s a canvas too. I have a room with big windows so I didn’t want anything with glass because of reflections. I could hang it as it is but I think a frame will set it off beautifully in that room.
A young person can be open to ideas or perhaps hasn’t even seen all that much art. A Quality print can set them on the the road of appreciating and collecting art.
It’s an original, you know. I know it’s small but I live in a tiny flat. I’ve only ever had posters before. It will be the start of my etchings collection.
Me: You made a good choice there, it’s a very fine print.
No, I can’t take credit for that – I didn’t choose it. My grandmother gave it to me as a leaving home present. She knows a lot about printmaking and has beautiful ones I’ve always admired at her house. It’s a real treasure.
Some reactions to presents that don’t fit with the recipients style or taste.
You get the person rushing in with something that they actually don’t like but had been given by someone they knew very well, perhaps their mother-in-law.
Desperate and feeling Guilty they haven’t dealt with it earlier:
Oh help! I’ve got to get this on the wall! It’s got to be displayed!
They’re coming to visit tomorrow – I can’t just stick it in the loo!
We would fix it up as fast as possible, preferably with some attention to style so that it doesn’t grate every time they see it. We have been known to succeed to the extent that the picture stays on the wall long after the end of the visit:)
Loving and anxious
The same sort of present, something that they don’t really like but they want to please the giver.
The present reflects the taste of the giver, reminds the receiver of the person who gave it to them and makes them feel good. They are willing to take the time to get it right.
It’s not really something I would have chosen but I’d like to try and fit it in with my place…
We would then take extra care so that it will look good, even discussing where they might want to to put it.
By fitting in with their style they could live with it, enjoying it every time they pass.
So on the one hand, a present in the taste of the giver gave a problem, and on the other gave something that prompted happy thoughts.
Getting the Happiest Reaction is Best
I don’t want to imply that there were a lot of complaints about the presents that people were given. I mean people are mostly grateful and were touched by receiving a gift, whatever it was,
but they sometimes produced embarrassment or discomfort.
People would say that the item was:
- Too expensive (forever indebted to them).
- Too posh (makes all my stuff look shabby).
- Too big (they simply had no room).
- The collection was misunderstood (People who collected paintings or etchings of a particular subject would suddenly get a photograph of it that doesn’t fit in their collection).
In spite of that, they have it framed because they were fond of the person and didn’t want to offend them but it was never going to produce the Delight and joy that was hoped for.
It’s not easy to give a work of art as a present. There can’t be any absolute rules but a little research and observation will go a long way towards ensuring that your gift is happily received.
Making a list of questions to ask to help you arrive at the right piece to give someone, or at least to give you an idea of what to look for and what to dismiss is a useful way to start.
